Prawo do autorstwa i współautorstwa : (uwagi na tle orzeczenia Sądu Najwyższego z dnia 25 maja 2011 r., II CSK 527/10)

2012
journal article
article
dc.abstract.enThe author addresses the problem of authorship and co-authorship in the context of the decision of the Supreme Court from 25 May 2011 (II CSK 527/10) concerning the copyright, but with some implications for scientific publications in general. The court's decision in question is important for the co-authorship and was rendered with regard to a medical publication of a rather popular character. The Supreme Court stated inter alia that a "verification of a scientific work consisting in removing scientifically questionable fragments amounts to co-authorship". One may express serious doubts whether the judgment is correct and could foster adequate interpretation of law and the establishing of good academic practice. Although co-authorship in the field of science is a controversial issue, which is notoriously difficult to regulate properly by law, and although custom and fairness very often play the prominent role, the analyzed judgment must be treated with caution. This is because taking into consideration both the facts of the case, as well as the result by which persons verifying a given text and making editorial changes (e.g. deleting some fragments) could be regarded as co-authors. The article argues that such an approach to a creative contribution cannot be approved. Nevertheless, the problem of proper designation of a "scientific contributions" (not being copyright works as such, but eligible for protection under Articles 23 and 24 of the Civil Code as a "scientific creations") deserves some effort.pl
dc.affiliationWydział Prawa i Administracji : Zakład Prawa Autorskiegopl
dc.contributor.authorStanisławska-Kloc, Sybilla - 132059 pl
dc.date.accession2018-12-12pl
dc.date.accessioned2018-12-12T08:47:59Z
dc.date.available2018-12-12T08:47:59Z
dc.date.issued2012pl
dc.date.openaccess0
dc.description.accesstimew momencie opublikowania
dc.description.additionalBibliogr. w przypisach. Streszcz. w jęz. ang. s. 58.pl
dc.description.number2pl
dc.description.physical39-58pl
dc.description.versionostateczna wersja wydawcy
dc.identifier.doi10.26106/9y1f-ty82pl
dc.identifier.issn1641-1609pl
dc.identifier.projectROD UJ / OPpl
dc.identifier.urihttps://ruj.uj.edu.pl/xmlui/handle/item/63503
dc.identifier.weblinkhttp://www.transformacje.pl/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/tpp_2-2012_stanislawska-kloc.pdfpl
dc.languagepolpl
dc.language.containerpolpl
dc.rightsDozwolony użytek utworów chronionych*
dc.rights.licenceOTHER
dc.rights.urihttp://ruj.uj.edu.pl/4dspace/License/copyright/licencja_copyright.pdf*
dc.share.typeotwarte czasopismo
dc.subtypeArticlepl
dc.titlePrawo do autorstwa i współautorstwa : (uwagi na tle orzeczenia Sądu Najwyższego z dnia 25 maja 2011 r., II CSK 527/10)pl
dc.title.alternativeRight to authorship and co-authorship : (remarks to the judgment of the Supreme Court from 25 May 2011, case docket III CSK 527/10)pl
dc.title.journalTransformacje Prawa Prywatnegopl
dc.title.volumeZeszyt jubileuszowy dla pani profesor Janiny Preussner-Zamorskiejpl
dc.typeJournalArticlepl
dspace.entity.typePublication
dc.abstract.enpl
The author addresses the problem of authorship and co-authorship in the context of the decision of the Supreme Court from 25 May 2011 (II CSK 527/10) concerning the copyright, but with some implications for scientific publications in general. The court's decision in question is important for the co-authorship and was rendered with regard to a medical publication of a rather popular character. The Supreme Court stated inter alia that a "verification of a scientific work consisting in removing scientifically questionable fragments amounts to co-authorship". One may express serious doubts whether the judgment is correct and could foster adequate interpretation of law and the establishing of good academic practice. Although co-authorship in the field of science is a controversial issue, which is notoriously difficult to regulate properly by law, and although custom and fairness very often play the prominent role, the analyzed judgment must be treated with caution. This is because taking into consideration both the facts of the case, as well as the result by which persons verifying a given text and making editorial changes (e.g. deleting some fragments) could be regarded as co-authors. The article argues that such an approach to a creative contribution cannot be approved. Nevertheless, the problem of proper designation of a "scientific contributions" (not being copyright works as such, but eligible for protection under Articles 23 and 24 of the Civil Code as a "scientific creations") deserves some effort.
dc.affiliationpl
Wydział Prawa i Administracji : Zakład Prawa Autorskiego
dc.contributor.authorpl
Stanisławska-Kloc, Sybilla - 132059
dc.date.accessionpl
2018-12-12
dc.date.accessioned
2018-12-12T08:47:59Z
dc.date.available
2018-12-12T08:47:59Z
dc.date.issuedpl
2012
dc.date.openaccess
0
dc.description.accesstime
w momencie opublikowania
dc.description.additionalpl
Bibliogr. w przypisach. Streszcz. w jęz. ang. s. 58.
dc.description.numberpl
2
dc.description.physicalpl
39-58
dc.description.version
ostateczna wersja wydawcy
dc.identifier.doipl
10.26106/9y1f-ty82
dc.identifier.issnpl
1641-1609
dc.identifier.projectpl
ROD UJ / OP
dc.identifier.uri
https://ruj.uj.edu.pl/xmlui/handle/item/63503
dc.identifier.weblinkpl
http://www.transformacje.pl/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/tpp_2-2012_stanislawska-kloc.pdf
dc.languagepl
pol
dc.language.containerpl
pol
dc.rights*
Dozwolony użytek utworów chronionych
dc.rights.licence
OTHER
dc.rights.uri*
http://ruj.uj.edu.pl/4dspace/License/copyright/licencja_copyright.pdf
dc.share.type
otwarte czasopismo
dc.subtypepl
Article
dc.titlepl
Prawo do autorstwa i współautorstwa : (uwagi na tle orzeczenia Sądu Najwyższego z dnia 25 maja 2011 r., II CSK 527/10)
dc.title.alternativepl
Right to authorship and co-authorship : (remarks to the judgment of the Supreme Court from 25 May 2011, case docket III CSK 527/10)
dc.title.journalpl
Transformacje Prawa Prywatnego
dc.title.volumepl
Zeszyt jubileuszowy dla pani profesor Janiny Preussner-Zamorskiej
dc.typepl
JournalArticle
dspace.entity.type
Publication
Affiliations

* The migration of download and view statistics prior to the date of April 8, 2024 is in progress.

Views
3
Views per month
Views per city
San Jose
2
Bobrowniki Male
1
Downloads
stanislawska-kloc_prawo_do_autorstwa_i_wspolautorstwa_uwagi_na_tle_orzeczenia_2012.pdf
18
stanislawska-kloc_prawo_do_autorstwa_i_wspolautorstwa_uwagi_na_tle_orzeczenia_2012.odt
13