W dniach od 2 kwietnia do 5 kwietnia 2024 r. prowadzone będą prace związane z wdrożeniem nowej wersji systemu Repozytorium UJ. Nie będzie możliwe wprowadzanie nowych informacji do repozytorium. Za utrudnienia przepraszamy.
The article discusses three theories of the representation of historical past – Collingwood’s, Veyne’s and White’s. The first was considered too naive, the second too skeptical, and the third as aimed openly against the reality of history. According to the author, however, they all reflect our longing for the past, yet each of them corresponds to another moment of it. The first to the longing for closeness, the second for strangeness, and the third for a principle. All these theories, even though different from each other, address the narrative aspect of historiography – its novel-like quality – with equal force. Each of the three historians confronts a historian with a writer. For Collingwood, a historian works using his imagination, like a novelist, to reenact the past. For Veyne, the author of history was an author of a novel, since like a writer he was forced to create cohesive and interesting narrations from the pieces of history, passing over the gaps in fragmentary sources. Whereas White remarked that a historian is always a narrator who, not unlike a novelist, structures his story according to a certain a priori determined pattern – thus he pointed out the similarity between historiography and belles-lettres at the deep structure level.
pl
dc.subject.en
imagination
pl
dc.subject.en
representation
pl
dc.subject.en
belles-lettres
pl
dc.subject.en
narration
pl
dc.subject.en
Robin G. Collingwood
pl
dc.subject.en
Paul Veyne
pl
dc.subject.en
Hayden White
pl
dc.description.volume
14
pl
dc.description.number
1
pl
dc.description.publication
1
pl
dc.title.journal
Sensus Historiae
pl
dc.language.container
pol
pl
dc.date.accession
2015-03-09
pl
dc.affiliation
Wydział Filologiczny
pl
dc.subtype
Article
pl
dc.rights.original
CC-BY; otwarte czasopismo; ostateczna wersja wydawcy; w momencie opublikowania; 0